interviewed by
Luiz Roberto Oliveira and Sergio Lima

English translation by
Jerry Lombardi



PART TWO





The model

< Edu Lobo: For me Tom was always a kind of model, an objective, something like that. I think it was that way for everyone in my generation. My thing is to make my music come as close as possible to that model, that harmonic and melodic rigor. I think he was very important in the sense of attracting people to that music, such that they wouldn't be drawn to some other kind of music.

 

Commercial music

Including because of the fact that in Tom's music you have millions of examples of songs that became extremely well known, and that are extremely commercial in the best sense of the term; I mean "Girl from Ipanema" is an extremely commercial piece of music and it's a masterpiece at the same time... It's absolutely well made, well constructed.
LR: "One-Note Samba" is also commercial beyond belief.
EL: "Desafinado" is fantastic and it wasn't even that commercial in its day. It became commercial, but at the time it was extremely revolutionary. Nobody was composing like that.
LR: "Desafinado" was the most incredible thing...
EL: Yeah, and now my first recollection of it, I remember.... I always do this test with everyone and I'm gonna do it with you too. Do you remember the first time you heard "Chega de saudade"? Remember where you were?
LR: I was with Carlinhos Lyra at a guitar lesson, and he played a little bit of it.
SL: I heard it on the radio. I was living outside the city at the time.
EL: Which means you remember the first time you heard that music. Everyone I've ever talked to remembers. Caetano remembers, Chico remembers. Everyone I've ever asked, they remember. I remember where I was, I was in Recife, it was a summer day... "What is this?" I couldn't even figure out who was singing, it was that recording by João (Gilberto)... It wasn't even the kind of thing you'd like right away, it was like you'd listen and just sit with it for a while, and listen again..."What are these lyrics? What is this music? What kind of singing is this? What kind of guitar playing is that?" There was nothing like it at the time. And there were other things that were so good..
LR: But nothing like that one, no way.
EL: But there was Caymmi, Custódio's songs, Ary Barroso, millions of the most beautiful things. There was Villa-Lobos and so on, but it didn't have that...
SL: Freshness.
EL: That's why when you think about all the junk they wrote about Bossa Nova, I think even the name is sort of dumb because it doesn't convey anything. For you to say that Tom was a bossa nova composer is very limiting...
LR: It limits his scope.
EL: Yeah, exactly, and afterwards he went on to explore other spheres.
SL: His thing is just so vast, if you turn on that novela "O Rei do Gado" ("The King of Cattle"), there's "Correnteza", which every cleaning lady knows how to sing, everybody sings it.
EL: Yeah, and they already used "Luiza" as the opener for a novela. And that's a hard tune to sing, it's got these intervals that people usually goof up on, but... anyway, they sing it.

 

The two buzzards

EL: EL: Now, aside from that there's something else: he was one of the funniest people I ever knew. With a sense of humor that was very personal, there was a kind of code you had to know in order to understand Tom. There were some people who didn't get it at all. Because he was a guy who, in the middle of a conversation, would start telling a story about buzzards, for example. He would invent so many stories, and he would go on with them for like fifteen, twenty days. And if you ran into him three times he never remembered that he'd already told it to you and he'd tell it all over again. And then after the twenty days were over he'd be coming at you with a new story. He had thousands of them, but there's one I remember particularly, the one about the buzzards, which went like this: "Do you know the story about the buzzards that were flying around?" (laughter) It's not a joke! This is a story he made up. "There were two buzzards flying side by side and all of a sudden an airplane passed by, way up high overhead. So they flipped upside down, looking up at the plane, and one of them tapped the other one with the tip of his wing and said: 'Boy, Walter's really gotten rich hasn't he?'" (laughter)
EL: That is not a joke, I never heard that as a joke, it's a story he made up... And I remember at the time Walter Clark was at TV Globo, but he was really talking about Walter Moreira Salles, the richest man in Brazil. You just remember those things. Also I remember when we were recording the album, with a lot of ballads and so on, and in the studio next to us there was a rock group - I don't recall which one - that was also recording. They were real serious, very "dark", all dressed in black, dark sunglasses and the whole thing. And Tom said: "How amusing, here we are singing our heartbreaking ballads and dying laughing at the same time, and there they are, playing their stuff and looking as depressed as can be"... It's true, they were playing rock, and there we were: (singing) "Farewell, come back Luiza..." and as soon as the track was laid down it was straight back to the jokes, Walter the buzzard and all that craziness. Just nonstop silliness. Puns, plays on words. He was a pun specialist, from the worst to the best, he was very funny.

 

Theater Album

SL: There's a story about him and Chico fighting over reading dictionaries...
EL: There was the thing about the dictionaries. They had every dictionary in the world.
SL: And when you and Chico recorded 'Corsário do Rei' ('The King's Buccaneer'), you called Tom to record and...
EL: 'Choro bandido'. Which was dedicated to him, by the way.
SL: And which is very pretty. I know of three recordings of it, including yours, but that one was untouchable.
EL: We used that one just now, on a new disc called "Album de Teatro", which is coming out in November.
LR: With all the theater compositions you did with Chico.
EL: With all the compositions we did for the theater, Chico and I. And it has that very recording on it, which has such a nice feel to it, a great feel. And that composition, when it was finished I said: "Chico, this tune has 'Tom' written all over it" and so we wound up dedicating it to him, and that was actually before Chico wrote the lyrics. Of all the tunes I did, I think it was the one he liked most.

 

An ear for music

LR: He would listen to everything, wouldn't he?
EL: Everything.
LR: An ear for music...
EL: Yeah, an ear for music. He didn't have perfect pitch and he complained about it. He talked about that a little bit. He used to say that the engineers had perfect pitch.
LR: The engineers?
EL: Yeah, he used to say: "The engineers have perfect pitch, but I don't". I don't know if he felt sorry about it, but at the same time he knew that was stupid. You can have perfect pitch and not have much musical sense.
LR: He was above all that.
EL: He used to say: "Did you know that Stravinsky also didn't have perfect pitch?" But Tom had an ear, a sensibility for music, that was extraordinary. I don't know how many times I saw him do something like, for example, he'd hear a certain chord and his arm would get goosebumps right away. He'd say: "Ooh, listen to this" and then he'd play it. It was an instant reaction to something that really touched him emotionally, he was not just pretending.

 

Leadership

EL: He was a total musician, a complete musician, and that's why I say once again that his importance for our generation is enormous. Because since we idolized Tom's style so much, we had to study it, I mean when we played the guitar in those days we didn't know shit, not me, not you, nobody. So in the end I think it was extremely important, his leadership.
LR: He radiated tremendous energy, an enormous stimulus for every musician...
EL: No doubt about it. But then there was that horrible thing in Brazil, a period when it was supposedly bad to study, because you'd lose your authenticity...
LR: Your naturalness.
EL: But I think in Brazil any time you have an attitude about studying, it creates this kind of totally reactionary, dangerous idea. There are so many stories... because Caymmi tried to study with Guerra Peixe and Guerra Peixe supposedly said: "Ah! No, don't mess with that, if it ain't broke don't fix it..." y'know? Maybe that story's not even true. However, I think there is such a thing as a natural composer...
LR: Like Caymmi. Dorival Caymmi is a natural composer.
EL: What I can't agree with is that if Caymmi had studied, if he had decided to study, it would've been bad for him, you know? Obviously not. I mean, to say that studying is harmful to your work, for somebody's composing...
LR: And Tom studied music.
EL: He studied piano. He studied orchestration, he studied the classics. If you could augment your vocabulary, then obviously it will help you write better. Your talent won't change, that stays the same, right? You either have it or you don't. If you don't have any talent it won't do you any good to study, the best you can hope for is to become a good musicologist. But if you have the talent, if it can be developed, why not? Your hearing can be developed, it can improve, you become a better listener.
LR: You understand music better.
EL: It'll be good for you, obviously. All that, just to get back to the subject of Tom.

End of Part Two.


Home Page in English